City Scape
About Us Newsletter
Events
History
Map
Places of Interest
Newsletter
Help Line
Membership
Links
Business Directory
Advertising
Contact Us

EYE on BUSINESS

…Featuring neighborhood establishments
that help make Turtle Bay a special place to live and work

 

L. Simchick Prime Meats & Fresh Poultry

Leonard Simchick’s butcher shop is a tiny, unpretentious-looking place – 400 square feet in an 1850s corner building at First Avenue and 52nd Street.  But his meats and poultry are served at some very big, important tables.

Ever the discreet shopkeeper, Leonard won’t even hint at the names of the hosts and hostesses who serve his products, but it can be assumed they include lots of celebrities, heads of state and high-level diplomats.  “There are some very big private dinner parties in the area,” Leonard says, lowering his voice as though he’s telling a neighborhood secret. The private chefs and cooks for these parties are among Leonard Simchick’s best customers. 

But along with the chefs, L. Simchick also has plenty of “do-it-yourself” neighborhood customers.  On a recent day when the Turtle Bay Newsletter stopped by to chat with Leonard, a neighbor came in to buy two lamb chops, cut two inches thick; a chef who was planning a party for his boss came by to order veal for eight people, cut for osso bucco; and another customer asked for advice on cooking a rib roast before ordering one for her holiday dinner.

Leonard sells prime meats, all cut to order (including many international cuts, a “must” in such a diverse neighborhood as Turtle Bay, he says).  His poultry is all natural, raised on small farms.  He also offers a wide variety of game, delicacies and an array of prepared specialties.

While most of Leonard’s customers are from Turtle Bay and surrounding neighborhoods, his shop’s reputation is citywide.  In the 2005 Zagat Survey of Gourmet Marketplaces,
L. Simchick is tied for first place for quality and service among all New York City meat markets.  (The other is Lobel’s on the Upper East Side.)

Leonard’s knowledge of the business goes back a long way.  When he was a boy growing up in a small Pennsylvania town, he and his family lived above his father’s butcher shop.  As a child, he played in the store, and as a teenager he worked there on weekends and during school vacations.

So when it came time to choose his life’s work, Leonard wasn’t so sure he wanted to become a butcher. “I’d spent too many hours of my boyhood in my dad’s butcher shop,” he says.  He went to college and got into the import-export business.  But by the time he was 32 years old, the office environment seemed too confining and Leonard started to re-think the butcher business.  

To learn the trade (re-learn, in Leonard’s case), he spent seven years working in butcher stores in New York (his apprenticeship, he calls it), and then he started looking for a shop of his own. That was in 1992. As it turned out, just a year earlier, the historic A. Fitz & Sons butcher shop, located in this small space at 944 First Avenue, had finally closed after more than 130 years in business. Leonard leased the empty storefront and opened L. Simchick Prime Meats & Poultry.  “It was just me, a delivery guy and no customers,” he says of those first days in the business. But very quickly, customers who had shopped at A. Fitz started coming in, and through word of mouth alone (he’s never advertised), Leonard’s business grew rapidly.

He attributes much of his success to his shop’s location. “The neighborhood’s affluence and international nature are ideal for a specialty butcher shop like mine,” he says. 

But no doubt quality and service are the real reason for his shop’s success.  “We have always been a small, old-fashioned butcher shop, and that’s the way I want to keep it,” he says.  “Too many butchers today standardize their cuts of meat.” He points to his butcher block, placed right in the center of the store.  “When I cut meat for my customers, I like to think that I’m bringing my ‘block’ right into their kitchen,” he says.  “I want to do it their way.” 

With a philosophy like that, it’s easy to see how L. Simchick has earned its fine reputation.

Store hours: Mon.-Fri., 8 a.m.-7 p.m.

Sat., 9 a.m.-6 p.m.

 

Back



Home | About Us | Announcements | History | Map | Places of Interest | Newsletter
Help Line | Membership | Links | Yellow Pages | Advertising | Contact Us

Turtle Bay Logo

The Turtle Bay Association is a nonprofit (501c3) community organization.

224 East 47th Street, New York City 10017
(212) 751-5465
Fax (212) 751-4941

 

E-Mail Home